问HN:人工智能代理与用户界面/用户体验设计的未来。大家有什么看法?

4作者: jackmenotti大约 1 个月前原帖
我是一名程序员,主要从事各种用户界面(UI)的开发。无论是桌面应用、游戏还是网页,我都做过。虽然有人称我为前端开发者,但我认为这个称谓最近被赋予了许多负面情绪(有些是应得的,有些则不是)。无论如何,我热爱在任何表面上渲染内容,对用户界面/用户体验(UI/UX)充满热情,并坚信在任何环境中做好UI/UX都是非常困难的。与我多年来遇到的许多开发者不同,他们喜欢批评用户界面,并低估构建成功用户体验的复杂性,尤其是在需要处理多种分辨率、高性能图形渲染、流畅动画、效果/着色器、可访问性、可用性等诸多因素时。 最近,我看到关于人工智能代理(AI Agents)出现了许多有趣的讨论,讨论它们如何塑造人类互动的未来,使用户界面变得过时,并扰乱用户界面设计,或者威胁那些通过自身用户界面掌控数据/服务的公司。如果他们不适应并开发人工智能代理集成,可能会被淘汰,但这种集成的代价可能是大型科技公司的人工智能锁定。这让我思考了很多,我并不担心自己的工作,实际上我对此充满热情,但也有一些不确定性。因此,我在这里列出了一些观点,真的很想听听这个社区的意见。 * 聊天机器人或代理仍然是一种用户界面,只是以不同的形式呈现的用户体验?我个人认为聊天机器人是“专业化”的用户界面,就像我认为游戏一样。 * 聊天机器人的回复已经嵌入了丰富的小部件,以改善用户体验,有时没有什么比一个老旧的表格更适合展示结构化数据,因此我并不认为用户界面组件会消失。 * 那么,谁会阻止人们在 booking.com 上开发一个代理集成,生成一个在我的主屏幕上显示当前优惠摘要或价格跟踪图表的丰富小部件呢? * 即使所有的交互都是音频,我们仍然需要制定一些“音频用户体验”指南,以创造出色的音频体验,不是吗? * 在漫长的交互列表中,我觉得我们可能会想要看到和/或触摸某些东西,我是说我们仍然是人类,人类喜欢可以触摸的物理事物,比如按按钮。 * 我们也不应忘记用户界面可能作为备用或出于可访问性目的而存在,因此我看不到用户界面会消失,反而可能会变得多模态和适应性更强? 你怎么看?
查看原文
I&#x27;m a programmer, mostly working on UIs of any kind. Desktop, games, web, I did them all. One would call me a frontend developer although I think this title has been overloaded with negative sentiments lately(some deserved some not imo). Anyways I love making stuff render on any surface, I&#x27;m really passionate about anything UI&#x2F;UX and I strongly believe doing good UI&#x2F;UX in any context is very hard. Contrary to many developers I met over the years that love to hate UIs and underestimate the complexity of building a successful user experience, especially when you have to deal with multiple resolutions, performant graphics rendering, smooth animations, effects&#x2F;shaders, accessibility, usability and many more.<p>Lately I&#x27;ve seen the rise of many interesting discussions around AI Agents, how they could shape the future of human interactions, making UIs obsolete and disrupting UI Design, or jeopardising companies that are gate keepers of their data&#x2F;services through their own UI, if they won&#x27;t adapt and develop an AI Agent integration they might be left behind, but the price of such integration might be big tech AI lock-in. That gave me a lot of food for thought, I&#x27;m not worried about my job, I actually am an enthusiast but also have some uncertainties. so I&#x27;m leaving here some points below and I&#x27;d really like to hear some opinions from this community.<p><pre><code> * A Chatbot or Agent is still a UI with some kind of UX but in a different form? I personally see Chatbots as &quot;specialized&quot; UIs like I think games are. * Chatbot responses do already embed rich widgets for improving the UX, and sometimes nothing better than a good old table exists for showing some structured data, so I don’t necessarily see UI components going away. * Then who would stop one to develop an agent integration on booking dot com that would produce a rich widget on my home screen with a summary of current offers or a price tracking chart? * And, even if it&#x27;s all audio interactions we would still need to develop some &quot;Audio UX&quot; guidelines for making great audio experiences or not? * At some point in the long list of interactions, I feel like we may want to see and&#x2F;or touch something, I mean we still are humans, and humans like physical things to touch, like pushing buttons. * Let&#x27;s should not forget UIs may also exist as a fallback or for accessibility purposes, so I can’t see UIs going away, rather them becoming multimodal and adaptable maybe? </code></pre> What are your thoughts?