问HN：你认为新的MCP替代方案会有用吗？
大家好，
我一直在研究MCP，但不断发现以下几个问题：
- 中间件服务器感觉完全不必要，而且过于复杂
- 由于标准似乎匆忙推出，存在太多安全漏洞
- 文档极其不足，让人感到困惑
我在考虑是否要开发一个新的协议，但我对那幅老漫画（https://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/standards_2x.png）心有余悸。
我想问问大家——尝试构建一个新的可扩展、安全的MCP版本是否有价值？
还是说我应该继续使用目前流行的协议？
查看原文
Hi everyone,<p>I've been wrestling with MCP, and keep finding the same weaknesses:
- the middleware server feels completely unncessary and overly complex
- it has too many security flaws due to what feels like a rushed out standard
- it's just so poorly undocumented and confusing<p>I've been thinking of doing a new protocol, but am too aware of that ol' comic (https://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/standards_2x.png)<p>Yet was curious to ask you guys - is there value in trying to build a new scalable, secure version of MCP?<p>Or should I just stick to the protocol that's currently popular?