展示HN:开发者萎缩测试——没有AI你还能编码吗?
嘿,HN,
我是来自Scrimba(YC S20)的Per,一个代码学习平台。
最近关于AI工具是否导致开发者技能退化的讨论越来越多。我们对此有着直接的观察,发现越来越多的学生在基本概念和独立构建应用方面遇到困难。这几乎总是过度依赖ChatGPT和“随意编码”工具的结果。
因此,我们开发了一个小项目:
[https://devatrophy.com](https://devatrophy.com)
这是一个测试你核心网页开发知识的工具——没有手把手指导,没有额外帮助,也没有AI自动补全。只有你、你的大脑和10个问题。分为三个级别(新手、高手、硬核),问题涵盖HTML、CSS、JavaScript、数据库和Node。
最后你会得到一个分数,还有一个可以下载的证书,供你炫耀(或被公开羞辱)。
希望你能试试,并告诉我们你的想法。同时也很想知道你自己或你的团队是否感受到“开发者技能退化”的迹象?
PS:具有讽刺意味的是,我们决定通过“随意编码”在V0上制作这个项目。哦,真是讽刺。
查看原文
Hey HN,<p>I'm Per from Scrimba (YC S20), the code-learning platform.<p>There's been a lot of talk lately about whether AI tools are causing skill atrophy amongst developers. We get a front-row seat to this, and we see more and more students struggle with basic concepts, and building apps on their own. This is almost always a consequence of relying too much on ChatGPT and vibe coding tools.<p>So we built a small side project:
<a href="https://devatrophy.com" rel="nofollow">https://devatrophy.com</a><p>It's a test of your core web dev knowledge — no handholding, no back rubs, no AI autocomplete. Just you, your brain, and 10 questions. There are three levels (Noobie, Le Chad, Hardcore), and the questions cover HTML, CSS, JavaScript, databases, and Node.<p>You’ll get a score at the end, plus a downloadable certificate for bragging rights (or public shaming).<p>Would love for you to try it and tell us what you think. And would be curious to hear if you're feeling any signs of "dev atrophy" yourself, or in your team?<p>PS: Ironically we decided to produce it by vibe coding on V0. Oh the irony.