问HN:Azure DevOps 是否实际上已经结束生命周期?
我并不讨厌 Azure DevOps。相反,在过去五年多的时间里,它对我们组织来说是一个出色的工具。它的安全性相对容易保障,我们有很多优秀的管道来检查我们的代码、进行部署、与第三方服务集成等。我们对组织的运作有很好的可视化了解。
但是……我不禁觉得它跟不上 GitHub 的步伐,现在面临的问题是:如果我们想保持相关性,是否基本上没有选择,只能痛苦地迁移到 GitHub Enterprise?
特别是我们感受到的痛点:
1. Copilot 的 PR 审查在哪里?在 GitHub 上,我只需点击一个按钮,就能获得 Copilot 对任何 PR 的即时初步审查。当然,这并不完美,但基本上是免费的。
2. MCP?好吧,DevOps 终于有了一个 MCP 服务器,而且实际上还不错。但它的推出花了很长时间。这会是一个重复的模式吗?我们必须等上一年才能获得 GitHub 用户立即可以使用的工具?
3. Claude Code。在 GitHub 上,我可以从任何地方给 Claude Code 分配任务——浏览器、桌面、手机——它会在一个小的开发容器中运行,并将 PR 返回给我。同样,这并不总是完美的,但初级开发者的 PR 也不一定完美。而且 Claude Code 不在乎我是否在周五晚上给它分配任务。
所以,标题中的问题是:ADO 是否实际上已经到了生命周期结束的阶段?
我希望答案是否定的,我们可以坚持到情况好转。不过,我开始担心这只是沉没成本谬论。无论如何,有什么希望可以提供吗?
查看原文
I don't hate Azure DevOps. On the contrary, it's been a phenomenal tool for our organization over the past 5+ years. It's been fairly easy to secure, we have tons of great pipelines that check our code, do deploys, integrate with third-party services, etc. We get great visibility into our organization.<p>But... I can't help but feel like it's not keeping up with GitHub and am now facing the question: do we basically have no choice but to do a painful migration over to GitHub Enterprise if we want to stay relevant?<p>In particular, pain we've felt:<p>1. Where's the Copilot PR review? In GitHub I just click a button and I get an instant first level review of any PR by Copilot. Sure, it's not perfect, but it's more or less free.<p>2. MCP? Ok there finally is an MCP server for DevOps and it's actually pretty good. But it took forEVER to come out. Is this a pattern that's going to repeat? We have to wait a year for tools GitHub users get right away?<p>3. Claude Code. On GitHub I can give Claude Code assignments from anywhere -- browser, desktop, phone -- and it runs off in a little dev container and comes back to me with with a PR. Again, not always perfect, but neither are PRs from junior devs. And Claude Code doesn't care if I give it the assignment on a Friday night.<p>So the titular question: Is ADO effectively EOL?<p>I'm hoping the answer is no, and we can just hold on till things get better. I'm starting to worry, though, that this is just the sunk cost fallacy. Anyway have hope to offer?