问HN:未来每个人的电脑上都会运行100个MCP进程吗?
关于MCP与CLI,我有一些不理解的地方:
权限:你已经可以为CLI命令设置权限范围。
可发现性:你已经可以通过帮助标志发现命令和参数。
为什么要在计算机上增加一个全新的进程?
MCP的支持者是否设想未来你电脑上的每个程序都有另一个MCP进程在运行?
这似乎是在增加额外的复杂性和可移动部分,但收益却不大。
查看原文
Some things I don't understand with MCP vs. CLI<p>Permissions: you can already scope CLI command permissions<p>Discoverability: you can already discover commands/arguments with a help flag<p>Why add a whole other process to the computer?<p>Do MCP proponents imagine in the future every program on your PC has another MCP process also running?<p>It seems like adding extra complexity/moving parts for not much benefit.