HackerNews中文版

我注意到，最近那些因被迫接受人工智能热潮而感到疲惫的软件工程师的异议声音似乎越来越响亮。就在本周，我在这里（例如[1]、[2]）和Reddit上（例如[3]、[4]）阅读了几篇帖子，评论数达数百条，许多开发者已经从怀疑和矛盾的情绪中走出来，进入了悲伤的五个阶段中的一个或多个。这并不是说他们是大多数：那些“我用人工智能工作效率提高100倍”、“我已经几个月没手动编码，感觉很好”、“适应或被淘汰”的真信徒们的帖子并没有减缓，仍然占据着大部分，尤其是在LinkedIn等地方，在这些地方表达异议可能会对你的工作和未来的就业能力产生现实影响（我可能是因为被裁员而痛苦地领悟到这一点，原因是模糊的“失调”）。但无论如何，从温和的怀疑者到彻底的反对者，非信徒们似乎比六个月或一年前更加直言不讳。问题： 1. 你也注意到这种变化了吗，还是只是我的社交媒体算法更频繁地推送这些内容？ 2. 在接受这一切成为新常态之前，我们（开发者）实际上能做些什么？提前退休是一个选择，有些人已经选择了这一道路（[5]）或计划在未来几年内这样做。我也在认真考虑提前退休（至少是离开科技行业），但最近我接到了一位招聘人员的联系，提到一个职位，其中包括“零人工智能辅助编码”。我眼前一亮，但这也让我思考：是否还有更多这样的公司在低调运营？一群发声强烈、反抗的开发者宣称“我不会被欺负、羞辱或被迫进行代理编码”，是否真的能改变人工智能编码不可避免的叙述？那些反对的公司和创始人是否可以开始宣传“有机的、人工编写的”代码作为一种质量信号和吸引拒绝屈从于人工智能要求的经验丰富工匠的福利？也许我只是在做白日梦，以上所有问题的答案都是“不”，但我仍然处于悲伤的早期阶段，介于否认和愤怒之间，而不是抑郁，更不用说接受了。 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48668199 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48651675 [3] https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/1ueidyv/software_engineers_are_facing_an_identity_crisis/ [4] https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/1ufed4k/software_engineers_are_facing_an_existential/ [5] https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/1uew891/older_tech_workers_are_tapping_out_taking_early/

查看原文

It seems to me that the dissenting voices from software engineers burned out after having the AI hype shoved down their throats have been growing louder lately. Just this week I read several posts both here (e.g. [1], [2]) and on Reddit (e.g. [3], [4]) with hundreds of comments from devs who have long moved past skepticism and ambivalence into one or more of the five stages of grief.That's not to say they're the majority by any means: the "I am 100x more productive with AI," "I haven't hand-coded in months and love it," "adapt or become irrelevant" posts by True Believers haven't slowed down and still make up the lion's share, especially on places like LinkedIn, where voicing dissent can have real-world consequences for your job and future employability (I may have learned this the hard way after being laid off for nebulous "misalignment" reasons). But still, the non-believers, from mild skeptics to full-on haters, do seem more vocal than, say, six months or a year ago.Questions:1. Have you noticed this shift too, or is it just my social media algorithm surfacing these more?2. What can we (devs) realistically do before accepting this as the new normal? Early retirement is one option, and some have already taken it ([5]) or plan to in the coming years.I'm seriously considering early retirement too (at least from tech) but I was recently contacted by a recruiter for a role that, among other things, mentions "zero AI-assisted coding." My eyes lit up, but it also got me thinking: are there more companies like this just keeping a low profile? Could a critical mass of vocal, defiant devs proclaiming "I will not be bullied, shamed, or forced into agentic coding" actually shift the narrative that AI coding is inevitable? Could contrarian companies and founders start advertising "organic, human-written" code as a quality signal and a perk for attracting experienced craftsmen who refuse to bow to AI mandates? Maybe I'm just daydreaming and the answer to all of the above is no but I'm still early in the grieving process, somewhere between denial and anger rather than depression, let alone acceptance.[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48668199[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48651675[3] https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/1ueidyv/software_engineers_are_facing_an_identity_crisis/[4] https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/1ufed4k/software_engineers_are_facing_an_existential/[5] https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/1uew891/older_tech_workers_are_tapping_out_taking_early/

问HN：是否存在一个“没有强制AI”的开发工作安静市场？